Sometime in the mid-1980s, I started keeping mental catalogs of sounds, methods, genealogies and connections. Who influenced whom. What came before what. Why something that seemed new was actually a response to something older and stranger.

I was lucky to come up in a scene that takes music seriously as an art form. Buffalo in that era had Hallwalls, CEPA Gallery, and the people who came through for shows, residencies and arguments. I could run into Tony Conrad on a Tuesday (not even knowing his full history at the time) and spend the rest of the week thinking about his influence on bands I was just learning about.

What I didn’t understand at the time was that I was building a trap.

Knowledge accumulates differently than experience does. Experience builds calluses and instincts. Knowledge, at a certain density, can start to build walls.

After several decades of seriously researching and making music, I had a fully developed internal critic that could immediately name the context of anything I was making. I could hear the precedents in any chord progression, its limitations, and the more sophisticated version someone else had already made in 1973.

That isn’t useful when you’re trying to make something.

It produces a kind of paralysis that can look a lot like taste. You stop things before they become themselves because you already know where they’d rank. The critic, who knows four decades of experimental music history, is faster than the composer.

I had been drawn to experimental and minimal music because those traditions seemed to reject that kind of thinking: the idea that music needed to justify itself through complexity or novelty, and the idea that composition was a competition with the past. I’d turned even that into a trap. I knew so much about how Feldman placed sounds that I couldn’t place a sound without thinking about Feldman.

The document I started calling Koans for the Studio came out of that frustration. I had been working on instrumental material with my collaborator Steve, guitar and bass, using a generative process: jam, record, let it sit, come back to it. I kept reaching past what we were actually making toward some idea of what it should be, a more considered version that would justify all the listening I’d done.

A koan isn’t meant to give you more information. It’s meant to interrupt the part of you that processes information, so that something underneath it can work. One of the first I wrote:

The room is already full. You are not adding sound: you are choosing which silence to keep.

I started writing them as a way of talking to myself in the studio, a voice that cut through the critic instead of feeding it.

The document grew past aphorisms. I wanted to understand, at a practical level, how composers I’d respected for decades had made things under the weight of everything they knew. What Radigue’s process looked like, what constraints she set, what she was listening for, as opposed to what she meant or represented. What Reich found when his tape loops drifted apart. What Neubauten learned from hitting steel with a hammer, which is less about ideology than about what happens acoustically when you let a struck object set its own rhythm.

A lot of this came into focus through Joy Division, which may seem strange, since they aren’t minimalist composers by any usual definition. But when I looked closely at what the band was doing harmonically, I found something I’d been circling for years.

They weren’t building toward resolution. In a lot of their songs, the verses don’t resolve into choruses, and the choruses don’t close. The music works through its emotional content without delivering it to a conclusion.

What I’d been hearing as darkness or tension was, at least in part, a structural choice. It was the opposite of the verse-chorus-resolution structure I’d spent decades pushing against without realizing it, even while I kept using it.

So the way out was already in what I knew. I just hadn’t looked at it from that angle.

The document is now something like amy studio bible: koans, practical methods, composer profiles and a listening path. It has entries on Eastman, Palestine, Z’EV, Oliveros, Lachenmann and Amacher, among others. It has methods for using a pedal tone, for blurring relative major and minor, for putting a contact mic on a steel pipe. The listening path is meant to walk someone from process music through drone, silence, material and voice.

None of it is information I didn’t already have in some form.

What it gives me is permission, pulled out of forty years of listening and reorganized into something I can actually use in the studio. The people in it found ways to make something profound out of very limited means, and most of them did it by not letting everything they knew about music get between them and the sound they were making.

That’s what I’m still trying to learn.

The narrower the means, the deeper you’re forced to listen.